
- Advanced Photonics
- Vol. 6, Issue 2, 026007 (2024)
Abstract
1 Introduction
Wavelength-selective photodetection has been widely applied in nondispersive infrared sensing, biofluorescent imaging, spectral imaging, optics communication, surveillance, and machine vision,1
In this paper, near-infrared (NIR) photodetection with a normalized response bandwidth of 0.17% was demonstrated experimentally in Au/Si Schottky nanojunctions. Due to the low-loss plasmonic resonance supported by Au-covered shallow silicon gratings, the linewidth was reduced to 1/20 of the conventional prism-coupled SPR supported by a planar Au film on quartz. Grating height, light-source divergence, and linewidth were manipulated to push the limit of the measured photodetection bandwidth down to 2.6 nm at a wavelength of 1550 nm. Benefiting from the narrowband resonance and the strongly localized SPR field, a refractive index detection limit down to was achieved. Furthermore, self-contained on-chip optical sensing was realized with in situ hot electron (HE)-based photoelectric conversion in such a metal-semiconductor (MS) nanojunction. Bio/chemo sensing on both glucose and goat IgG solutions was conducted, demonstrating excellent sensing performance comparable to bulky commercial biosensing instruments.
2 Materials and Methods
2.1 Optical Simulation
Absorption spectra and electromagnetic field distribution were simulated by using the finite-difference time-domain method. The structure parameters are given in the figure legends. Periodic boundary conditions were applied in the grating plane and perfectly matched layer boundary conditions were applied in the direction along light transmission. Polarization was set to be perpendicular to the grating direction.
2.2 Device Fabrication
Nanogratings in a layer of 500 nm thick photoresist (Shipley 1805) were first patterned on a 10 cm n-Si wafer () using a Nikon NSR i-line stepper. A dry etching process was adopted to transfer the patterns into Si with reactive ion etching (RIE, Tegal 903e). A stack of 10 nm and 200 nm was deposited outside the grating region () as an insulator layer for electrode deposition (15 nm Ti/100 nm Al/15 nm Ti/100 nm Au). In comparison, a stack of 1 nm Ti and 60 nm Au was deposited in the grating region by magnetron sputtering. Successively, Al film (300 nm) was deposited on the entire rear side of a wafer. The whole wafer was cut into small pieces () and then bonded with the microfluidic channels in PDMS. The complete devices were mounted on printed circuit board and linked electrically by wire bonding.
2.3 Optical and Optoelectrical Measurements
A high-power supercontinuum laser (NKT Photonics) coupled with acousto-optic tunable filters (AOTFs) was employed as a monochromatic and linearly polarized (1:100) light source in optical and optoelectrical measurements. The reflection spectra were collected by scanning the wavelength of this laser source and recording the power of the reflected light by a power meter (Thorlabs PM100D). The near-field mapping experiments were performed by the s-SNOM (Neaspec GmbH). A tunable laser (Santec, TSL-570) with a linewidth of 1 pm is also used for accurate spectral measurement for comparison. All the electrical characteristics, including the curves and the time-resolved currents, were collected using a source meter (Keithley 2636B).
In the glucose and rabbit IgG sensing experiments, solutions with different concentrations were injected to the sensor via the microfluidics. The surface of the Au film of the sensor was functionalized with the goat anti-rabbit IgG. Rabbit IgG solutions with three different concentrations were prepared for biosensing experiments.
3 Results
The proposed narrowband NIR PD, which consists of Au-covered Si gratings, is shown in Fig. 1(a). The corrugated Au film has dual functions, i.e., supporting SPR for spatial/spectral engineering and acting as an electrode for HE emission. On the one hand, a Schottky junction is formed at the Au/Si interface and the ohmic electrode is formed at the back side of the Si substrate. As a result, interband transition in Si dominates the photoelectric response under illumination with a wavelength smaller than 1100 nm, while the photogenerated HEs,27
Figure 1.Au-covered Si gratings used for narrowband NIR photodetection. (a) Schematic of the proposed Au/Si nanojunction. Surface localized plasmonic resonance supported by the Au/Si gratings is plotted with an overlap to the gratings, which is expected to improve the surface sensing. The
3.1 Narrowband Plasmonic Resonance
Considering the actual requirements of high yield and low cost in device fabrication, sub-100 nm nanostructures such as nanoantennas and several tens of layers of multilayer stack such as DBRs were not considered in our design. Instead, gratings with a period between 800 and 1200 nm were adopted, which can be patterned in a single lithography step in seconds on a whole 10 cm silicon wafer (see Sec. 2). The gratings couple the on-resonance incident light to SPR supported by the corrugated Au film, forming a strongly localized surface mode, as shown in Fig. 1(a). Each PD has an active region of defined by the metallic gratings, and microfluidics were integrated on top of the device for the following sensing experiments, as shown in Fig. 1(c). The three-dimensional profile of Au/Si gratings was measured using AFM, where the sharp contrast at the boundaries indicates the well-controlled lithography and dry-etching processes, as shown in Fig. 1(d). The numerical simulation in Fig. 1(e) clearly shows the surface-confined optical resonance in the near field (see Sec. 2). The maximum field components can be seen around the corners of the gratings, and the asymmetry is caused by the oblique incidence (3 deg) to mimic the experiments in scattering-type scanning near-field optical microscopy (s-SNOM) (see Sec. 2). The results of the SNOM mapping in Fig. 1(f) agree well with the simulation results. The strongly localized field components at the grating surface verified by both simulation and experiment results demonstrate the promising potential to boost the photodetection efficiency (increase light absorption in Au) and further reduce the detection limit of optical sensing (increase the sensitivity to the surface environment).
Narrowband resonance can be clearly seen from the calculated absorption spectra of the Au/Si gratings, as shown in Fig. 2(a), where the resonant wavelength, i.e., the operating wavelength band of the PDs, can be continuously tuned by simply changing the grating period. It is a major advantage over the vertical cavity PD for mass manufacturing, particularly for a PD array with various operating wavelengths. As seen, there is only one absorption peak in a broad band of 800 to 1800 nm with low background and sidelobes due to the continuous Au film, which is important for nondispersive infrared (NDIR) sensing to exclude the interference signal. An FWHM of 6.49 nm is observed with an absorption peak at 922 nm for , i.e., a normalized bandwidth of 0.7%. Because the spectral photoelectric response of this PD is mainly determined by the resonance, it is reasonable to expect similar narrowband photodetection performance, which suggests its promising applications in biosensing and spectral imaging. To evaluate the impact of a resonant linewidth on the sensing performance, a series of normalized Lorentz-type curves with different FWHMs, as shown in Fig. 2(b), were used to mimic the resonance spectra of plasmonic sensing structures. Assuming a same resonance shift of 2 nm, the maximum amplitude change of a resonance with a small linewidth () is 28 times that of a resonance with a large linewidth (), i.e., the detection limit is expected to be reduced by more than 1 order of magnitude by using a narrowband resonance. Therefore, it is important to find out the major factors associated with the resonance linewidth in both design and experiment.
Figure 2.Optical characterization of Au/Si gratings. (a) Simulated absorption spectra for
3.2 Dominant Factors of Resonant Linewidth
Using a time-domain coupled mode theory, the guide line for designing a narrow-band resonance can be obtained (Supplementary Material S2). Basically, there are two main loss mechanisms of such one-port resonant configuration. One is the absorption loss associated with the lossy metal; the other is the radiative loss caused by the leaky modes of the gratings. A perfect matching between the absorption loss and the radiative loss leads to unity light absorption at resonance. The radiation loss is mainly determined by the grating height, and thus shallow gratings are required for a narrow linewidth. The absorption loss is less sensitive to the structure dimensions, and it sets the lower limit of the linewidth. As shown in Fig. 2(c), an FWHM of 6.9 nm in calculation is obtained at with a peak absorption of 100%. With the increase of the grating height, the FWHM increases up to 40 nm for . Although an FWHM of 3 nm can be obtained at , the absorption is less than 34%, which is caused by the mismatch of absorption loss and radiative loss. These theoretical and numerical results are verified by the experiment results, as shown in Fig. 2(d), where the normalized absorption spectra were obtained from the measured reflection spectra (no transmission from the back side of the Si). The FWHM monotonically decreases from 31.3 to 5.7 nm when the grating height continuously decreases from 80 to 20 nm. Therefore, shallow gratings fabricated with stable processes are preferred. In addition, by increasing the grating period at a fixed grating height, as shown in Fig. 2(a), the FWHM of the absorption peak keeps decreasing down to 2.65 nm for with a normalized bandwidth of 0.15%, which is much smaller than the results in the literature (Table S1 in the Supplementary Material). The small FWHM at a large period is determined by the reduced radiative loss due to the small normalized grating height (normalized to the resonance wavelength).
Apart from the impact of structure design and fabrication process, the divergence and the linewidth of the light source were found to be also key factors in determining the measured resonance linewidth. In the experiments, the reflection spectra were measured in a scanning mode using a supercontinuum laser source connected with an AOTF. Due to the grating coupling mechanism in the excitation of SPR in this device, the resonant absorption is sensitive to the incident angle, as shown in Fig. 2(e) (S3 in the Supplementary Material). With an increase of incident angle, a single resonance at normal incidence splits into two resonances, where the one shifting to the longer wavelength is st order resonance and the other shifting to the shorter wavelength is st order resonance. For an incident angle of 20 deg, the calculated resonant shifts of both st and st order resonances reach , which agree well with the experiment results in Fig. 2(f). In a case of divergent incident light, different SPR resonances can be excited at different angles, i.e., the absorption band inevitably extends to a broad wavelength range. In addition, the spectral resolution of the AOTF also limits the minimum measured linewidth. Because the spectral sampling of the plasmonic structures was obtained by continuously tuning the passband of the AOTF, the resonance in the measured spectrum would be broadened if its linewidth is smaller than the width of the passband of the AOTF, which is 10 to 15 nm in NIR. As shown in Fig. 2(g), the width of the AOTF passband was assured in calculation to be 0.1, 1, 5, 10, and 20 nm, respectively, where the simulated absorption spectra mimicking the wavelength-scanning measurement process were obtained by the integration of the filtering response of the AOTF and the absorption spectrum of the Au/Si gratings. Therefore, the calculated results are dependent on the passband linewidth of the AOTF. For a narrowband filtering setting of the AOTF (e.g., 0.1 nm), the calculated linewidth is mainly determined by the linewidth of the absorption spectrum of Si/Au gratings. In contrast, for a broadband filtering setting of the AOTF (e.g., 20 nm), the calculated linewidth is mainly determined by the passband linewidth of the AOTF. In addition, the peak absorption decreases at a broadband filtering setting of the AOTF due to the overall increasing illumination power in a broad band for normalization. This phenomenon was also observed in experiments, as shown in Fig. 2(h), where the black line was measured using a supercontinuum laser source with an AOTF (the FWHM is 10 to 12 nm), and the red line was measured with a tunable laser (Santec, TSL-570) with a linewidth of 200 kHz. Therefore, a narrow linewidth laser source is preferred to maximize the excellent sensing performance in terms of intensity interrogation for sensing.
3.3 Narrowband Plasmonic Photodetection
Based on the above optical measurement, the photoelectric properties of an optimized PD were further characterized, as shown in Fig. 3. The curves under laser light illumination at a wavelength of 1342 nm show a clear Schottky junction behavior, as shown in Fig. 3(a). By continuously switching the wavelength of the laser light illumination by an AOTF, the photocurrent spectrum was recorded, as shown in Fig. 3(b). From 850 to 950 nm, there is only one photocurrent maximum at 914 nm associated with the resonant absorption with low background, which indicates the expected wavelength-selective photodetection. The absorption spectra of this device were obtained from the measured reflection, as shown in Fig. 3(c). The measured resonance wavelength is in an excellent match with the simulation due to the well-controlled grating period in stepper lithography. An absorption peak at 914 nm with an FWHM of 6.44 nm can be seen at normal incidence. The lower peak absorption, slightly larger background, and broader resonance ( in simulation) in experiments were attributed to the measured error [as discussed in Figs. 2(e)–2(h)] and the fabrication errors on the gratings. Compared to the widely used prism-coupled SPR () in biosensing,37 the resonant linewidth of the plasmonic gratings () is much smaller, as shown in the inset of Fig. 3(b). The photoelectric responses follow the optical properties exactly as shown in Fig. 3(d), where a responsivity peak at 914 nm with an FWHM of 6.69 nm was also observed. The normalized response bandwidth is 0.7%. Please note that the FWHMs of the peaks around 914 nm in Figs. 3(b)–3(d) are all overestimated due to the limited spectral resolution of the AOTF used, as shown in Figs. 2(g) and 2(h). To calibrate the devices more accurately, the measurement was also conducted in a wavelength range about 1550 nm, where a tunable laser source with a spectral resolution down to 1 pm was used. To do so, an oblique incidence angle of 45 deg was applied to shift the resonance from 914 to 1550 nm. As shown in Figs. 3(c) and 3(d), a peak at 1550 nm was observed with an FWHM of 2.65 and 2.6 nm in the absorption and photoelectric response spectra, respectively. The associated normalized response bandwidth is 0.17%, which is the smallest linewidth of PDs, to the best of our knowledge. Such an on-chip narrowband photodetection with low background in a broad wavelength range shows great potential in NDIR gas sensing, biofluorescent detection, and high-accuracy spectral sensing.38
Figure 3.Optoelectronic characterization of the proposed narrowband PDs. (a) Power-dependent photocurrent of the on-resonance device. The incident beam (launched by a 1342 nm laser) was fixed at an incident angle of 28.7 deg. The inset is the output
3.4 On-Chip Optical Sensing with In Situ Photoelectric Conversion
Optical sensing techniques have unique advantages, including high accuracy, low time delay, and a spectral fingerprint. However, encoding a target signal to light and converting a light signal to an electric signal for easy readout are usually achieved in two separated components in conventional optical sensing platforms. As a result, such a bulky and complex system (e.g., spectrometer) is difficult to be incorporated in on-site sensing platforms. In contrast, the proposed sensor is fully self-contained, where plasmonic nanogratings not only enable strong optical field confinement and narrowband resonance for sensing but also provide high light absorption and in situ HE emission for photoelectric conversion.
First, we evaluate the bulk sensitivity of such a device, which is associated with refractive index variations in the whole environment around the device. In simulation, assuming a solution with uniform refractive index distribution filling the entire space surrounding the device, the calculated absorption spectra are shown in Fig. 4(a). Redshift of the resonance is observed when the refractive index increases. For , a redshift of is obtained, indicating a sensitivity of , as shown in Fig. 4(b), where the figure of merit () reaches 220. Assuming a spectral resolution of 1 nm (1 pm), such a sensitivity gives a detection limit of () for a conventional wavelength-interrogation sensing mechanism based on spectrometers. Instead, a sensing signal can also be extracted by a simple amplitude interrogation, which excludes the requirements on an expensive spectrometer. As shown in Fig. 4(b), light absorption decreases from 73.6% to 22.6% at for . A sensing experiment was conducted with a glucose solution. In general, increasing the concentration of glucose causes the increase of the refractive index of the solution and thus the redshift of the plasmonic resonance. At the initial stage, the device covered with deionized water has a resonance at , which is slightly larger than the laser illumination wavelength (1342 nm). Therefore, a decrease of the output current was observed with the increasing of the glucose concentration, as shown in Fig. 4(c). For a refractive index variation from deionized water to a glucose solution (1%), the current changes 276.6 nA. Considering the noise level of 1.3 nA, the detection limit is (i.e., ) assuming a linear relation between the refractive index and the concentration. Glucose sensing experiments were also conducted on a same device with different laser sources (Supplementary Material S5), where it was found that the sensing signals of a laser with a narrower linewidth are larger than the one with a wider linewidth.
Figure 4.Sensing performance of the narrowband plasmonic PD. (a) Calculated absorption spectra in the case of bulk sensing.
In contrast to bulk sensing, surface sensing is associated with the detection of thin films or bio/chemo interaction on the surface, where the refractive index variation only occurs in a region close to the sensor surface. Because the resonant field intensity of SPR usually decreases exponentially with a distance away from the surface, it is necessary to evaluate the surface sensing performance independently. Assuming a conformal thin film of is deposited on top of the plasmonic gratings, it induces a redshift of the calculated absorption spectrum, as shown in Fig. 4(d). For a 2 nm thick , the resonance shift is 1.6 nm around and the absorption reduces from 71.3% to 45.9%, as shown in Fig. 4(e). By shifting the resonance to 1550 nm at an oblique incidence angle of 45 deg, decreases to 0.42 nm for the same 2 nm film due to the further extension of the plasmonic field distribution. Therefore, the minimal detectable thickness of the film via the wavelength interrogation is less than 1.25 pm assuming a spectral resolution of 1 pm. In addition, the resonance shift becomes saturate when the film thickness increases beyond 500 nm because the surface mode becomes weak at the positions farther away from the sensor surface. Similarly, in surface sensing, a device with shallow gratings () has much larger absorption variation than the one with deep gratings ().
To evaluate the actual biosensing performance of the proposed device, rabbit IgG detection was conducted. First, goat anti-rabbit IgG molecules in a concentration of were bonded onto the Au film at the sensor surface via covalent interaction. Then, rabbit IgG diluted with phosphate-buffered saline buffer in different concentrations was injected into the microfluidic in sequence. The interaction between rabbit IgG in the solution and the goat anti-rabbit IgG immobilized on the sensor surface was measured as a current signal in real time. As shown in Fig. 5, the current started to decrease right after the injection of the solutions with higher concentrations and became saturate after several minutes. It is because the capture of rabbit IgG in the solution caused an increase of the average refractive index in the region close to the sensor surface, and thus a redshift as in Fig. 4(a). The stable values of the current are , 2.65, and for 10, 50, and rabbit IgG, respectively. Considering the current noise of 20 nA during the measurement, the limit of detection (LOD) of rabbit IgG can be estimated to be , which is comparable to or better than most optical sensors in the literature. For example, H-shaped SPR fiber sensor showed an LOD of for human IgG.41 Decoration of nanostructures on Au-coated optical fiber obtained an LOD of for goat-anti-rabbit IgG.42 Immobilizing half-antibody fragments on an SPR fiber instead of antibody decoration reduced an LOD down to .43 Please note that all these measurements relied on a precise spectroscopy instrument with a spectral resolution of 20 pm. In addition, a commercial SPR sensing instrument (Biacore X100) has an LOD of for rabbit IgG.44 Therefore, the proposed self-contained plasmonic sensor based on a narrowband HE PD shows great advantages, with decent sensitivity, high integration, and low cost. Please note that this is the intrinsic sensing performance of the Au/Si gratings, and it could be significantly improved via advanced surface treatments and signal amplification techniques (e.g., graphene oxide and reduced graphene oxide decoration).43
Figure 5.Rabbit IgG detection experiment. (a) Schematic of plasmonic sensor surface modification and rabbit IgG detection process. (b) Real-time current output from the sensor with the rabbit IgG solution injection at three concentrations in sequence. The inset shows the noise level during the measurement.
4 Discussion
In this work, we demonstrated a narrowband PD (non-waveguide) with a record narrowband photoelectric response down to 2.6 nm at an operating wavelength of 1550 nm. Such a high wavelength selectivity in photodetection is expected to significantly improve the performance of sensing and spectroscopy. Continuous metal film covered shallow Si gratings were found to effectively suppress the radiative loss and thus support a narrow resonant linewidth with a low background signal in a broad wavelength range. Reducing light source divergence and linewidth was also suggested to realize narrowband photodetection. Benefiting from the HE based in situ photoelectric conversion in Au/Si Schottky junctions, self-contained on-chip optical sensing was achieved with an LOD of for rabbit IgG.
Long Wen is a professor at the Institute of Nanophotonics at Jinan University. His research interests center on the applications of plasmonics to infrared light detection, modulation, biosensing, and multifunctional nanodevices. Currently, he is particularly interested in the integration of nanophotonics with various applications-specific platforms, such as CMOS image sensor, semiconductor devices, and microfluidics for developing more compact optoelectronic devices and systems.
Dan Gao is an associate professor in Tsinghua International Graduate School at Shenzhen, Tsinghua University. Her research focuses on the development of novel methods based on microfluidics combined with mass spectrometry and spectroscopic techniques for drug analysis, novel organic synthesis and biosensors. She received her PhD from Beijing University of Chemical Technology, China.
Qin Chen is a professor at the Institute of Nanophotonics, Jinan University, China. He directs a micro/nano-optoelectronic device group. His research interests include nanophotonics, photodetection, optical sensing, micro-spectroscopy, etc. He has developed sub-ppm MIS junction hydrogen sensors, infrared enhanced CMOS image sensor, on-chip spectral sensor, etc. He received his PhD in microelectronics and solid sold electronics from the Institute of Semiconductors, Chinese Academy of Sciences, in 2006.
Biographies of the other authors are not available.

Set citation alerts for the article
Please enter your email address