• Laser & Optoelectronics Progress
  • Vol. 60, Issue 15, 1500007 (2023)
Yousi Yang1, Dan Li1,*, Encai Ji2,**, Xiaofeng Ji3,***..., Bing Tian4, Ping Yan1, Mali Gong1 and Qirong Xiao1|Show fewer author(s)
Author Affiliations
  • 1Ministry of Education Key Laboratory of Photonics Control Technology, Department of Precision Instruments, Tsinghua University, Beijing 100084, China
  • 2MIL Medical Technology (Shenzhen) Co., Ltd., Shenzhen 518000, Guangdong, China
  • 3Sanming First Hospital Affiliated to Fujian Medical University, Fuzhou 365000, Fujian, China
  • 4LAKH Medical Instruments (Beijing) Co., Ltd., Beijing 101300, China
  • show less
    DOI: 10.3788/LOP221852 Cite this Article Set citation alerts
    Yousi Yang, Dan Li, Encai Ji, Xiaofeng Ji, Bing Tian, Ping Yan, Mali Gong, Qirong Xiao. Thulium-Doped Fiber Laser and Its Applications in Laser Lithotripsy: Progress and Prospect[J]. Laser & Optoelectronics Progress, 2023, 60(15): 1500007 Copy Citation Text show less
    Cladding pumped thulium-doped fiber laser. (a) Schematic of laser; (b) external cavity for tunable operation; (c) output power versus launched pump power; (d) output power versus operating wavelength for cladding pumped 2.6 m fiber (inset: output power at 1941 nm versus launched pump power)[6]
    Fig. 1. Cladding pumped thulium-doped fiber laser. (a) Schematic of laser; (b) external cavity for tunable operation; (c) output power versus launched pump power; (d) output power versus operating wavelength for cladding pumped 2.6 m fiber (inset: output power at 1941 nm versus launched pump power)[6]
    Thulium-doped fiber laser amplifier with output power of 300 W. (a) Schematic of laser; (b) output power versus pump power[8]
    Fig. 2. Thulium-doped fiber laser amplifier with output power of 300 W. (a) Schematic of laser; (b) output power versus pump power[8]
    600 W single mode single frequency thulium-doped fiber laser amplifier. (a) Schematic of laser amplifier; (b) output power curve of single frequency amplifier; (c) output spectrum at 608 W (inset: OSA resolution limit of 0.05 nm)[2]
    Fig. 3. 600 W single mode single frequency thulium-doped fiber laser amplifier. (a) Schematic of laser amplifier; (b) output power curve of single frequency amplifier; (c) output spectrum at 608 W (inset: OSA resolution limit of 0.05 nm)[2]
    1000 W thulium-doped all-fiber laser. (a) Schematic of laser; (b) output power versus pump power[3]
    Fig. 4. 1000 W thulium-doped all-fiber laser. (a) Schematic of laser; (b) output power versus pump power[3]
    530 W thulium-doped fiber laser with all-fiber structure. (a) Schematic of laser; (b) spectrum with the output power of 500 W[12]
    Fig. 5. 530 W thulium-doped fiber laser with all-fiber structure. (a) Schematic of laser; (b) spectrum with the output power of 500 W[12]
    Tunable thulium-doped fiber laser at 2 µm. (a) Schematic of laser (internally marked a is the tuning structure and b is the free-running structure); (b) output power versus pump power; (c) output power of the tunable laser versus operating wavelength (inset: output power at 1930 and 1990 nm versus launched pump power); (d) spectral output of the grating-based laser and the free-running structures[15]
    Fig. 6. Tunable thulium-doped fiber laser at 2 µm. (a) Schematic of laser (internally marked a is the tuning structure and b is the free-running structure); (b) output power versus pump power; (c) output power of the tunable laser versus operating wavelength (inset: output power at 1930 and 1990 nm versus launched pump power); (d) spectral output of the grating-based laser and the free-running structures[15]
    Research scheme of high power tunable thulium fiber laser[11]
    Fig. 7. Research scheme of high power tunable thulium fiber laser[11]
    342 W narrow linewidth continuous-wave thulium-doped fiber laser with all-fiber structure. (a) Schematic setup of the seeder; (b) schematic setup of the two-stage amplifiers; (c) output power versus incident pump power[26]
    Fig. 8. 342 W narrow linewidth continuous-wave thulium-doped fiber laser with all-fiber structure. (a) Schematic setup of the seeder; (b) schematic setup of the two-stage amplifiers; (c) output power versus incident pump power[26]
    High-power thulium-doped superfluorescent fiber source. (a) Schematic of light source; (b) spectrum for the copropagating ASE; (c) spectrum for the counterpropagating ASE[30]
    Fig. 9. High-power thulium-doped superfluorescent fiber source. (a) Schematic of light source; (b) spectrum for the copropagating ASE; (c) spectrum for the counterpropagating ASE[30]
    Output signal in quasi-continuous-wave mode and continuous-wave mode
    Fig. 10. Output signal in quasi-continuous-wave mode and continuous-wave mode
    1940 nm quasi-continuous-wave thulium-doped fiber laser. (a) Schematic of the laser; (b) output power versus pump power at 793 nm; (c) output spectrum at the average power of 10 W[38]
    Fig. 11. 1940 nm quasi-continuous-wave thulium-doped fiber laser. (a) Schematic of the laser; (b) output power versus pump power at 793 nm; (c) output spectrum at the average power of 10 W[38]
    564 W quasi-continuous-wave thulium-doped fiber laser. (a) Schematic of laser; (b) peak output power at 10 Hz and 5% duty cycle; (c) near-field (top) and far-field (bottom) beam profiles[39]
    Fig. 12. 564 W quasi-continuous-wave thulium-doped fiber laser. (a) Schematic of laser; (b) peak output power at 10 Hz and 5% duty cycle; (c) near-field (top) and far-field (bottom) beam profiles[39]
    Three quasi-continuous-wave thulium-doped fiber laser products. (a) TLM-50/500-QCW from IPG; (b) IFL QCW 650 from Futonics; (c) MIRON150/750 laser prototype from MIL MED TECH
    Fig. 13. Three quasi-continuous-wave thulium-doped fiber laser products. (a) TLM-50/500-QCW from IPG; (b) IFL QCW 650 from Futonics; (c) MIRON150/750 laser prototype from MIL MED TECH
    Single mode thulium fiber oscillator[42]
    Fig. 14. Single mode thulium fiber oscillator[42]
    Water absorption coefficient at different wavelengths[55]
    Fig. 15. Water absorption coefficient at different wavelengths[55]
    SOLTIVE™ Premium medical quasi-continuous-wave thulium-doped fiber laser system from Olympus
    Fig. 16. SOLTIVE™ Premium medical quasi-continuous-wave thulium-doped fiber laser system from Olympus
    LKSPTm120 laser treatment equipment from LAKH of China
    Fig. 17. LKSPTm120 laser treatment equipment from LAKH of China
    YearCentral wavelength /nmMaximum output power /WPumped power /WSlope efficiency /%All-fiber structure
    200251940740No
    20066199119.238.272No
    20066185112.123.159No
    200772050263~51159No
    200922040608>110054No
    20098204030950061.8No
    2010320451000>190053.2Yes
    20149190822744354.3Yes
    2015102000.3342>60056Yes
    2016111930327.557057.4Yes
    2020121980.89530>90050Yes
    Table 1. Main researches on high power thulium-doped continuous-wave fiber laser in recent 20 years
    YearWavelength /nmTunable range /nmTuning methodAll-fiber structureMaximum output power /W
    200251860-2090230Diffraction gratingNo7
    200661859-2061202Diffraction gratingNo19.2
    200661723-1973250Diffraction gratingNo12.1
    2010141927-2097170Diffraction gratingNo218
    2012151895-2109214Diffraction gratingNo62
    2013171820-2075255Tunable fiber grating filterYes0.03
    2015191966-200135Tunable bandpass filterYes>250
    2016121910-2050140Tunable bandpass filterYes327.5
    2017161679-1992313Diffraction gratingNo0.041
    2019212000-2172172Diffraction gratingNo0.53
    2020201930-200070DMD + fixed gratingNo3.16×10-5
    Table 2. Main researches on tunable thulium-doped continuous-wave fiber laser in recent 20 years.
    YearCentral wavelength /nmLinewidth /pmOutput power /W
    20102419902.2113/279
    2014251996.7<12010.5
    2016262000.390342
    2019271942.033.86×10-6(single longitudinal mode)>6
    2021281920-2010(tunable laser)1.29×10-3(single longitudinal mode)80
    Table 3. Main researches on narrow-linewidth thulium-doped continuous-wave fiber laser in recent 10 years
    YearCentral wavelength /nmLinewidth /nmMaximum output power /W
    2008291960>100>11
    2010301890800.06
    2015311960.74520.7
    2015311948.25025.2
    2017321860170>0.035
    2020331850>1550.09
    Table 4. Main researches on thulium-doped ASE continuous-wave source in recent 15 years
    IndexIPGFutonicsnLightMIL MED TECH
    Name of productTLM-50/500-QCWIFL QCW650TFL-60MIRON150/750
    Central wavelength /nm19431940±201940±101940±10
    Maximum mean power /W5015060150
    Maximum peak power /W500650600750
    Maximum pulse energy /J518748
    Pulse width /ms0.2-500.1-500.05-200.1-400
    Bandwidth /nm<2<110<1
    Repetition frequency /Hz0-25001-30001-100001-5000
    Cooling modeAir coolingWater coolingAir coolingAir cooling
    Table 5. Parameters of several typical products for quasi-continuous-wave thulium-doped fiber laser
    YearCentral wavelength /nm

    Mean power /W

    @ repetition frequency /kHz

    Monopulse energy /mJPeak power /kW@ pulse width /ns
    200740198330@1110.276.6@41
    20104119926.5@200.3252.6@125
    20124719984.35@100.4358.9@49
    2013421850 &190033@13.92.4150@15
    201543205040.5@40~110@100
    2018452000.216@250.6435.6@18
    20184419521.5@1000.0152.5@6
    20214619402.44@631.50.00387263@14.7
    20214818810.006@812460 nJ—@8.71
    202149~18910.395@980.640.3 nJ—@(14.1-23.6)
    Table 6. Typical research parameters of nanosecond short-pulsed thulium-doped fiber laser
    IndexHo∶YAGThulium-doped fiber laser
    Typical central wavelength2120 nm1940 nm
    Core diameter>200 μmThinner,50-150 μm is available
    BubbleLargerSmaller
    Pulse widthAdjustableLarger adjustment range
    Repetition frequencyAdjustableLarger adjustment range
    Cooling modeWater coolingAir cooling
    PowerHighHigh,but with lower peak power
    Ablation rateSlowerFaster,up to four times that Ho∶YAG
    RetropulsionLargerSmaller
    Irrigation rateLowerHigher
    SecurityHighHigher than Ho∶YAG
    Radiation and electrical hazardsLowLow
    NoiseGreaterLower
    Electro optic efficiencyLowerHigher
    Table 7. Comparison between thulium-doped fiber laser and Ho∶YAG laser[55, 61, 65]
    IndexOlympusEMSJena SurgicalLAKH
    Name of productSOLTIVE™ PremiumLaserClast Thulium PowerMultiPulse Tm + 1470LKSPTm120
    Central wavelength /nm1940±201940±201940,14701940±20
    Maximum average power /W6060120120
    Maximum peak power /W500500120500
    Maximum pulse energy /J66
    Pulse width /ms0.2-50>0.1>0.5>0.1
    Repetition frequency /Hz1-24001-2500 & CW1-1000 & CW1-2500 &CW
    Cooling modeAir coolingAir coolingWater coolingAir cooling
    Table 8. System parameters of several main medical quasi-continuous-wave thulium-doped fiber lasers
    Yousi Yang, Dan Li, Encai Ji, Xiaofeng Ji, Bing Tian, Ping Yan, Mali Gong, Qirong Xiao. Thulium-Doped Fiber Laser and Its Applications in Laser Lithotripsy: Progress and Prospect[J]. Laser & Optoelectronics Progress, 2023, 60(15): 1500007
    Download Citation