Author Affiliations
1Faculty of Land Resources Engineering, Kunming University of Science and Technology, Kunming 650093, Yunnan, China2Computing Center, Kunming University of Science and Technology, Kunming 650500, Yunnan, Chinashow less
Fig. 1. Proposed CNN
Fig. 2. Pseudo-color image and ground object truth map of the WHU-Hi-Longkou dataset. (a) Pseudo-color image; (b) real image
Fig. 3. Pseudo-color image and ground object truth map of the WHU-Hi-HongHu dataset. (a) Pseudo-color image; (b) real image
Fig. 4. Spectral information segmentation results on WHU-Hi-Longkou dataset. (a) KNN; (b) SVM; (c) RF; (d) CNN; (e) ground truth
Fig. 5. Spectral information segmentation results on WHU-Hi-HongHu dataset. (a) KNN; (b) SVM; (c) RF; (d) CNN; (e) ground truth
Fig. 6. Segmentation results of different hyperpixel algorithms on WHU-Hi-Longkou dataset. (a) SLICO; (b) PCA-SLICO; (c) SLIC; (d) PCA-SLIC; (e) MSLIC; (f) PCA-MSLIC
Fig. 7. Segmentation results of different hyperpixel algorithms on WHU-Hi-HongHu dataset. (a) SLICO; (b) PCA-SLICO; (c) SLIC; (d) PCA-SLIC; (e) MSLIC; (f) PCA-MSLIC
Fig. 8. Classification results of different methods on WHU-Hi-Longkou dataset. (a) PMS-KNN; (b) PMS-SVM; (c) PMS-RF;(d) PMS-CNN; (e) grouth truth
Fig. 9. Classification results of different methods on WHU-Hi-Longkou dataset. (a) PMS-KNN; (b) PMS-SVM; (c) PMS-RF;(d) PMS-CNN; (e) grouth truth
Category | KNN | SVM | RF | CNN |
---|
Corn | 94.93 | 98.41 | 88.53 | 98.45 | Cotton | 76.80 | 92.02 | 76.80 | 95.45 | Sesame | 82.96 | 98.25 | 82.21 | 98.70 | Round leaf soybean | 69.00 | 89.60 | 57.16 | 90.83 | Long leaf soybean | 88.30 | 96.05 | 69.80 | 97.91 | Rice | 99.24 | 99.48 | 64.20 | 98.68 | Wave | 99.87 | 99.88 | 92.18 | 99.83 | Houses and roads | 87.82 | 95.37 | 82.34 | 94.58 | Mixed weeds | 85.28 | 96.13 | 74.18 | 97.41 | OA /% | 89.88 | 96.77 | 82.51 | 97.18 | Kappa coefficient /% | 86.97 | 95.78 | 78.00 | 96.31 |
|
Table 1. CA of different algorithms on WHU-Hi-Longkou dataset
Category | KNN | SVM | RF | CNN |
---|
Roof | 84.37 | 76.02 | 78.67 | 92.17 | Road | 81.97 | 83.56 | 83.39 | 78.81 | Exposed soil | 63.15 | 74.45 | 65.50 | 73.66 | Cotton | 49.90 | 67.64 | 62.75 | 87.36 | Cotton wood | 60.21 | 78.70 | 68.05 | 64.24 | Rape | 66.54 | 81.40 | 72.56 | 92.47 | Chinese cabbage | 45.33 | 53.10 | 46.34 | 49.05 | Pakchoi | 38.80 | 39.56 | 20.93 | 58.84 | Cabbage | 88.38 | 89.18 | 84.81 | 88.28 | Mustard tuber | 38.70 | 47.20 | 40.47 | 66.60 | Cauliflower | 31.90 | 40.22 | 30.36 | 60.92 | Green vegetables | 56.95 | 54.81 | 54.33 | 61.74 | Small green vegetables | 45.56 | 49.12 | 52.04 | 71.80 | Asparagus lettuce | 61.54 | 56.82 | 44.33 | 50.75 | Lettuce | 87.30 | 80.42 | 73.91 | 82.85 | Film is covered with lettuce | 76.67 | 69.85 | 80.14 | 82.85 | Thin film covered with lettuce | 78.53 | 77.82 | 70.30 | 75.83 | Carrot | 68.37 | 73.40 | 68.31 | 84.24 | Ternip | 68.68 | 75.56 | 71.66 | 79.01 | Garlic bolt | 77.13 | 80.36 | 76.20 | 76.94 | Bean | 71.18 | 71.10 | 76.68 | 89.47 | Persimmon tree | 64.02 | 77.34 | 74.47 | 87.46 | OA /% | 63.02 | 72.68 | 68.26 | 85.43 | Kappa coefficient /% | 56.78 | 67.04 | 62.02 | 82.10 |
|
Table 2. CA of different algorithms on WHU-Hi-HongHu dataset
Category | PMS-KNN | PMS-SVM | PMS-RF | PMS-CNN |
---|
Corn | 97.74 | 99.64 | 94.37 | 99.85 | Cotton | 83.53 | 96.03 | 66.15 | 99.94 | Sesame | 89.90 | 98.06 | 83.03 | 98.35 | Round leaf soybean | 76.57 | 92.52 | 70.88 | 99.08 | Long leaf soybean | 93.84 | 97.02 | 76.10 | 99.15 | Rice | 99.62 | 9.540 | 99.08 | 99.67 | Wave | 99.88 | 99.87 | 99.85 | 99.72 | Houses and roads | 91.15 | 94.75 | 88.04 | 95.36 | Mixed weeds | 86.41 | 97.64 | 81.50 | 97.61 | OA /% | 92.76 | 97.80 | 89.35 | 99.45 | Kappa coefficient /% | 90.63 | 97.10 | 86.30 | 99.27 |
|
Table 3. CA on WHU-Hi-Longkou dataset
Category | PMS-KNN | PMS-SVM | PMS-RF | PMS-CNN |
---|
Roof | 95.62 | 80.33 | 93.58 | 98.38 | Road | 94.60 | 83.67 | 87.62 | 94.02 | Exposed soil | 87.36 | 91.36 | 86.13 | 96.33 | Cotton | 87.54 | 84.46 | 82.00 | 98.10 | Cotton wood | 92.34 | 84.39 | 91.18 | 99.45 | Rape | 87.99 | 87.79 | 86.40 | 96.57 | Chinese cabbage | 74.94 | 65.26 | 72.08 | 92.17 | Pakchoi | 86.60 | 17.60 | 77.20 | 99.95 | Cabbage | 96.28 | 91.77 | 94.73 | 97.60 | Mustard tuber | 73.43 | 66.86 | 76.93 | 96.85 | Cauliflower | 78.04 | 59.00 | 87.98 | 95.36 | Green vegetables | 86.78 | 56.75 | 85.84 | 96.27 | Small green vegetables | 74.96 | 73.16 | 76.14 | 97.06 | Asparagus lettuce | 86.90 | 64.80 | 87.98 | 97.22 | Lettuce | 94.66 | 67.80 | 99.00 | 100 | Film is covered with lettuce | 94.95 | 85.58 | 86.55 | 99.10 | Thin film covered with lettuce | 95.20 | 60.40 | 96.84 | 100 | Carrot | 94.42 | 78.54 | 95.64 | 99.40 | Ternip | 87.04 | 81.54 | 86.51 | 95.24 | Garlic bolt | 97.44 | 80.70 | 96.73 | 98.58 | Bean | 99.70 | 0 | 99.70 | 99.70 | Persimmon tree | 95.85 | 76.86 | 99.23 | 99.24 | OA /% | 88.97 | 82.90 | 86.84 | 97.60 | Kappa coefficient /% | 86.30 | 78.67 | 83.80 | 97.07 |
|
Table 4. CA on WHU-Hi-HongHu dataset