Long Huang1,2,†, Linhan Tang1,2,†, Yang Wang1,2, Minhui Cheng1,2..., B. E. Little1, Sai T. Chu3, Wei Zhao1,2, Weiqiang Wang4,5 and Wenfu Zhang1,2,*|Show fewer author(s)
1State Key Laboratory of Transient Optics and Photonics, Xi’an Institute of Optics and Precision Mechanics, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Xi’an 710119, China
2University of Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing 100049, China
3Department of Physics, City University of Hong Kong, Hong Kong 999077, China
4School of Electronic Information and Artificial Intelligence, Shaanxi University of Science and Technology, Xi’an 710021, China
Long Huang, Linhan Tang, Yang Wang, Minhui Cheng, B. E. Little, Sai T. Chu, Wei Zhao, Weiqiang Wang, Wenfu Zhang, "Multi-channel Hong–Ou–Mandle interference between independent comb-based weak coherent pulses," Photonics Res. 13, 837 (2025)
Copy Citation Text
【AIGC One Sentence Reading】:We demonstrate 16-channel HOM interference using independent SMCs, enhancing MDI-QKD feasibility with simplified frequency locking.
【AIGC Short Abstract】:We demonstrate 16-channel Hong–Ou–Mandle interference using weak coherent pulses from two independent frequency-aligned soliton microcombs, achieving over 46% visibility in all channels. This shows the feasibility of SMCs as multi-wavelength sources for quantum communication, reducing frequency locking complexity.
Note: This section is automatically generated by AI . The website and platform operators shall not be liable for any commercial or legal consequences arising from your use of AI generated content on this website. Please be aware of this.
Abstract
With the widespread application of quantum communication technology, there is an urgent need to enhance unconditionally secure key rates and capacity. Measurement-device-independent quantum key distribution (MDI-QKD), proven to be immune to detection-side channel attacks, is a secure and reliable quantum communication scheme. The core of this scheme is Hong–Ou–Mandle (HOM) interference, a quantum optical phenomenon with no classical analog, where identical photons meeting on a symmetric beam splitter (BS) undergo interference and bunching. Any differences in the degrees of freedom (frequency, arrival time, spectrum, polarization, and the average number of photons per pulse) between the photons will deteriorate the interference visibility. Here, we demonstrate 16-channel weak coherent pulses (WCPs) of HOM interference with all channels’ interference visibility over 46% based on two independent frequency-post-aligned soliton microcombs (SMCs). In our experiment, full locking and frequency alignment of the comb teeth between the two SMCs were achieved through pump frequency stabilization, SMC repetition rate locking, and fine tuning of the repetition rate. This demonstrates the feasibility of using independently generated SMCs as multi-wavelength sources for quantum communication. Meanwhile, SMC can achieve hundreds of frequency-stable comb teeth by locking only two parameters, which further reduces the complexity of frequency locking and the need for finding sufficient suitable frequency references compared to independent laser arrays.
1. INTRODUCTION
Photonic integrated circuits (PICs) have experienced significant advancements over the past few decades, particularly in the last 10 years [1–4]. This progress is attributed to significant advancements in micro-nano fabrication techniques, enabling the realization of large-scale, multifunctional PICs [5–7]. This notably reduces the complexity and cost of building optical systems, enabling large-scale integration and opening new avenues for generating thousands of optical qubits for quantum computing [8] and communication [9].
However, the rate of single-photon sources generated in current PICs and losses are insufficient for the demands of quantum communication [10]. Furthermore, the distance-capacity limit [11,12] constrains the feasibility of long-distance quantum communication, underscoring the urgent need for an increase in communication rates. One possible method is to use weak coherent pulses (WCPs) generated by attenuated light pulses instead of single photons [13], combined with traditional wavelength-division multiplexing (WDM) techniques, to enhance the capacity of long-distance quantum communication. For example, decoy-state techniques can be used to achieve quantum key distribution (QKD) through multi-path WCPs. However, traditional QKD schemes (i.e., BB84) have vulnerabilities, such as detector-side attacks [14], which can compromise the security of the system. With the proposal and demonstration of measurement-device-independent quantum key distribution (MDI-QKD) schemes, these vulnerabilities can be addressed [15]. MDI-QKD requires the deployment of two independent light sources, with Hong–Ou–Mandle (HOM) interference measurements conducted at a third party. Therefore, photon indistinguishability between the independent sources is a prerequisite for achieving high interference visibility, which is a necessary condition for efficiently extracting secure keys in these protocols [16].
When two indistinguishable photons impinge on a beamsplitter (BS), they exhibit “bunching”, known as HOM interference [17], which is a quantum optical effect with no traditional analog and has been observed in single-photon states [18], continuous-wave weak coherent states based-on SMCs [19], and thermal states [20]. When single photons are replaced by WCPs, HOM interference still occurs, but the visibility is limited to 50% [21]. To achieve high interference visibility, the WCPs must become highly indistinguishable, which requires precise control and monitoring of all degrees of freedom, such as frequency, arrival time, polarization, and the average number of photons per pulse.
Sign up for Photonics Research TOC. Get the latest issue of Photonics Research delivered right to you!Sign up now
Wavelength alignment is a critical challenge for independent laser sources without a common reference, and a simple solution is to reference the laser wavelengths to natural atomic transition lines. However, the limited availability of atomic reference frequencies makes it challenging to lock the frequencies of dozens or even hundreds of lasers. Fortunately, soliton microcombs (SMCs) [22] generated from on-chip integrated micro-ring resonators (MRRs) can effectively address this challenge. In the frequency domain, SMC is composed of a series of strictly equidistant spectral lines, with the comb teeth frequencies represented as , where n represents integer; and represent the frequency of the pump laser and repetition rate of the SMC, respectively. By locking and adjusting only two parameters, and , hundreds of precisely locked frequency comb teeth can be obtained. Compared to free-running SMCs already applied in traditional high-speed parallel communication [23,24], quantum communication schemes based on HOM interference have strict requirements for frequency alignment between independent light sources. Although, both and atomic reference schemes [25,26] have been developed in SMC frequency locking, and the frequency stability can reach beyond at 1 s, it is still a challenge to align all the frequencies of two independent SMCs due to the MRRs’ differences and the interaction between the optical frequency and repetition rate adjustment. The differences in the repetition rate of SMCs generated by different MRRs arise from two main sources: first, the slight discrepancies in the FSR due to fabrication errors (including the nonuniformity of film deposition, lithography, etching, etc.) [27]; second, variations in the soliton generation temperature and pump auxiliary power under pump-locked conditions, which result in different repetition rates [28]. Additionally, pump frequency locking prevents adjusting the repetition rate by changing the pump wavelength.
In this paper, we experimentally demonstrated HOM interference between 16 sets of WCPs based on comb tooth pairs generated by two independent on-chip SMCs. The frequency alignment and long-term stable operation of comb teeth between two independently generated SMCs are attributed to three operational aspects: first, the pump laser frequencies for generating the two independent SMCs are locked to same atomic transition from to using modulation transfer spectroscopy technology [29]; second, by employing pump power and temperature perturbations, we achieve a tuning of the repetition rates of two independently generated SMCs over 100 kHz based soliton steps exceeding 3 GHz; third, long-term stability of the repetition rate is achieved through microwave injection locking (MIL) technology [30]. Thanks to the above operations, the interference visibility of all channels’ WCPs HOM interference exceeds 46%, laying the foundation for long-distance, high-efficiency secure key extraction. Simultaneously, the development of quantum WDM technology at telecom wavelengths based on the MDI-QKD protocol becomes feasible, promising to further enhance the rates and user capacity of long-distance quantum communication.
2. PRINCIPLE AND EXPERIMENT
WCPs can be obtained by attenuating a laser. For two independently generated WCPs and with the same polarization state, their states can be expressed as where and represent displace operators. By adding a delay time to the input of path at times , as shown in Fig. 1(a), the states with the delay time before entering the BS can be expressed as
Figure 1.Schematic diagram of the principle of WCPs HOM interference. (a) Diagram of the principle of WCPs HOM interference; WCPs in paths and meet at a 50:50 BS and undergo HOM interference. (b) Typical HOM interference “dip”, with the right side (i)–(iii) indicating the relationship between photon indistinguishability and interference visibility at different optical delays.
Furthermore, in our experiment, the generated pulses are Gaussian weak coherent states, and their spectral function is expressed as where represents the central frequency of photons and ; is its spectral width. Assuming the detectors have a flat frequency response and the BS is an ideal 50:50 BS, the coincidence probability at the BS outputs and is given by [31] where the represents the HOM interference visibility, which is limited to 50% for WCPs between the independent input states and with , as shown in Fig. 1(b-iii). With the increasing delay time , will increase and interference visibility will decrease, as shown in Figs. 1(b-i) and 1(b-ii). At , the interference visibility decreases as the photon distinguishability increases. For WCPs generated by on-chip SMCs, the spatio-temporal mode and output polarization are ensured through chip design and coupling to a single-mode polarization-maintaining (PM) fiber. To align the pulses’ center frequency without a common reference, it is necessary to achieve independent full locking of the SMC and tuning of the repetition rate in the experiment.
Figure 2(a) shows the experimental setup for multi-path weak coherent pulse HOM interference based on independently generated SMCs. The two SMCs are generated in two independent high-index doped silica glass MRRs based on the well-developed AOM frequency-shifting laser-assisted intracavity thermal balance scheme. The MRRs [Fig. 2(e)] are packaged in 14-pin butterfly packages with thermo-electric coolers (TECs). The two pump lasers are independently referenced to the same atomic transition line to ensure frequency alignment of the pump lasers. The auxiliary lights are generated by AOM frequency shifting, which helps to further enhance the long-term stability of the SMCs (see Appendix A). The SMCs are coupled out through fiber arrays and phase-randomized by adding Gaussian white noise via PMs. The different frequency comb teeth are then separated using a commercial DWDM. Subsequently, the comb teeth are modulated into Gaussian pulses with a full width at half maximum (FWHM) of using an IM. While the pulses are attenuated to single-photon level and coupled into a 5:5 BS, HOM interference dip can be observed by adjusting relative delay time with optical delay lines between two-path WCPs.
Figure 2.Experimental setup. (a) Schematic diagram of the experimental principle of multi-path WCPs HOM interference based on independently generated SMCs. CW laser: continuous wave laser; : rubidium atom; AOM: acousto-optic modulator; IM: intensity modulator; RF: radio frequency; EDFA: erbium-doped fiber amplifier; μ-ring: microring; PM: phase modulator; DWDM: dense wavelength division multiplexing; VOA: variable optical attenuator; OD: optical delay; PC: polarization controller; SNSPD: superconducting nanowire single-photon detector; TCSPC: time-correlated single-photon counting. (b) The pump laser frequency is locked to atomic transition from to . (c), (d) and (f)–(h) Spectral output from different optical elements. (e) The picture shows the 14-pin butterfly-packaged MRR. Inset: magnified view of the MRR observed under a microscope. The loaded quality (Q) factor is .
The frequency alignment without common reference and long-term stability between the two independently generated SMCs are prerequisites for achieving multi-path WCPs HOM interference. Fully frequency-stabilized SMCs are achieved through atomic referencing and MIL. The pump lasers are frequency referenced to the transition spectrum line of to through the modulation transfer spectroscopy method. To appraise the frequency stability of the two locked lasers, we recorded the beat frequency by a frequency counter between the two locked 1560.492044 nm lasers. As shown in Fig. 3(b), the peak-to-peak frequency fluctuation of the two laser-locked pumps is 0.3487 MHz, meaning that each pump laser frequency drifts by , whose frequency fluctuation is much smaller than the spectral width () of the pulse generated from the comb tooth. The repetition rate of the free-running SMC fluctuates by due to dynamic changes in intracavity power and temperature. To further reduce the impact of repetition rate fluctuation on the instantaneous frequency of the comb teeth and the long-term stability of the SMC, the repetition rate of the SMC is locked to an ultra-stable external microwave signal through MIL. In our experiment, the pump laser generates a fourth-order sideband away from the pump laser using an IM driven by a microwave signal with frequency , aligning it with the repetition rate of the SMC. By comparing Fig. 3(c-left) with Fig. 3(c-right), the FWHM of the repetition rate signal is compressed by three orders of magnitude through MIL, which indicates successful transfer of the ultra-stable microwave signal stability to the repetition rate. Once the pump frequency and repetition rate are locked, the SMC source works at a rather stable state and can stably survive for a long time (over 5 days), which is suitable for future practical applications.
Figure 3.Results of two independently fully locked SMCs. (a) Single-soliton state spectra of two independently generated SMCs. The top left inset shows the comb teeth selected in the experiment for generating WCPs, along with their numbering. (b) The recorded beat signals of two atomic transition referenced pump lasers. The two locked lasers have the same average frequency of 192.1140573 THz with a peak-peak frequency fluctuation of 0.247 MHz in an hour. (c) Repetition rate signals of two independently generated SMCs in the single-soliton state: unlocked [left, (c)] and locked [right, (c)]. When the repetition rates are locked to ultra-stable microwave signals, the jitter of the repetition rate signal is reduced by three orders of magnitude compared to the unlocked state.
Moreover, due to fabrication errors, the intrinsic FSRs of the two MRRs used in the experiment differ by . This results in a frequency difference of between the nth comb tooth, generated by the two MRRs. This accumulation of frequency differences is highly detrimental to channels far from the pump, leading to a reduction in HOM interference visibility. This poses a challenge for using SMC-based DWDM systems in quantum communication. The AOM frequency-shifting laser-assisted intracavity thermal balance scheme used in our experiment for SMC generation allows for soliton steps exceeding 3 GHz, corresponding to a repetition rate tunable by more than 700 kHz theoretically under pump frequency locking conditions. As shown in Fig. 3(c-left), when reaching the single-soliton state in a microcavity, the repetition rates of the SMCs generated in the two different MRRs [as shown in Fig. 3(a)] differ by 108.8 kHz. By adjusting the beat signal between pump and auxiliary, and cavity’s temperature and pump power, we successfully shift the repetition rate of MRR1 to match that of MRR2 [Fig. 3(c-right)].
The SMC output from the MRR is phase-randomized by a PM loaded with 5 MHz Gaussian white noise, ensuring that the generated WCPs have a phase distribution randomly between 0 and 2π, thereby satisfying the phase randomization requirements for QKD [19,32]. Subsequently, the comb-teeth pairs with identical wavelengths are selected and modulated into pulses by IM with FWHM of (corresponding to a spectral width of ), as shown in Fig. 4(a). The repetition rate of the WCPs is set to 1.25 MHz. The photon counts of the two paths are attenuated to and , as shown in Fig. 4(b). Considering that the detection efficiency of SNSPD1 and SNSPD2 is , the average photon number of each path is estimated to be per pulse. Finally, the WCPs from two standalone SMCs are interfering at a symmetric polarization-maintaining BS. The two-path output photons are detected by SNSPD1(2) whose gate times are set to 1080 ps and the coincidence counts are analyzed by time-correlated single-photon counting (TCSPC). The trigger signal generated by the arbitrary waveform generator (AWG) is sent to the TCSPC to control the coincidence counting. The relative delay between the two independent WCPs is controlled by electronically controlled adjustable optical delay lines OD1 and OD2. The delay lines offer an adjustment precision of 5 fs, ensuring sufficient accuracy for the interference of two paths with pulse duration of .
Figure 4.WCPs generation. (a) The comb tooth of the SMC is modulated into pulses with an FWHM of using an IM. Inset: actual pulse fitted with theoretical Gaussian pulse. (b) The number of single photons from two-path independently generated WCPs recorded by the SNSPDs before interference. When no light is incident on the single-photon detector, the measured dark count rate of the single-photon counter is counts per second.
Figure 5(a) shows the experimentally measured normalized coincidence counts for the 16 channels of weak coherent states (points with error bars) and the theoretical fit with a Gaussian curve (colored continuous lines). Figure 5(b) shows the HOM interference fringe of channel 3, with the fringe visibility being estimated to be . The shape of the HOM “dip” retains a Gaussian curve, and the FWHM of the “dip” matches that of the Gaussian pulse. The experimental results are shown in Fig. 5(c), where the visibilities of HOM interference fringes are distributed from 46.02% to 47.17%. The high interference visibility provides a solid foundation for efficient and secure QKD.
Figure 5.HOM interference between two independently generated WCPs based on the SMCs. (a) The normalized coincidence counts between SNSPD1 and SNSPD2 versus the temporal misalignment adjusted by OD1 and OD2. The 16 channels in (a) correspond to the selected comb teeth shown in the inset of Fig. 2(a). (b) HOM interference fringe of channel 3 between two independent WCPs. The fringe visibility is estimated to be . (c) The HOM interference fringe visibility of 16 pairs of independent WCPs. The visibility is distributed in the range of 46.02%–47.17% with maximum standard deviation of for five measurements.
The implementation of multi-channel WCPs HOM interference using fully locked SMCs paves the way for quantum communication systems based on conventional fiber DWDM systems. However, any differences in the degrees of freedom (e.g., arrival time, spectrum, polarization, and the average number of photons per pulse) between the two independently generated sets of multi-channel WCPs will reduce photon indistinguishability, leading to a deterioration in HOM interference visibility. In our experiment, the independent WCPs are generated from two fully locked SMCs. The frequency differences between the comb teeth pairs () are much smaller than the pulse spectral width (), making the impact of pulse center frequency mismatch on interference visibility minimal. The SMCs are coupled into single-mode fibers, thus minimizing the impact of spatio-temporal mode differences. However, the main sources of error in this experiment arise from the non-ideal 50:50 BS used for interference, unequal detector efficiencies, the limited extinction ratio of the Gaussian pulses generated by the IM, as well as slight variations in pulse intensity and minor differences in modulation spectra [33,34]. In practical applications, it is necessary to further mitigate the effects of the complex environment on pulse polarization, delay, and pulse shape during long-distance transmission by incorporating polarization correction modules [35], time feedback techniques [36], and dispersion compensation [37] into the QKD system.
4. CONCLUSION
In our experiment, we successfully achieved 16-channel WCPs HOM interference with all channel visibility over 46% based on two independently generated SMCs. This paves the way for high-capacity, long-distance quantum communication using conventional DWDM systems without sacrificing security by introducing trusted nodes. The SMCs demonstrated in this work, with comb teeth frequency alignment achieved through independent locking and repetition rate tuning, can enable quantum communication protocols based on HOM interference (e.g., MDI-QKD). These protocols not only provide immunity to detection-side attacks, thereby enhancing the security of quantum communication, but also allow all users to share expensive resources (e.g., single-photon detectors), further reducing costs.
APPENDIX A: FABRICATION AND PACKAGING OF THE MRR AND SMC GENERATION
Fabrication and packaging of the MRR: The add-drop type MRR is fabricated on a CMOS compatible high-index doped silica glass platform, as shown in Fig. 6(c-II). The Q factor and FSR of the MRR are million and , as shown in Fig. 6(b), respectively. To couple the light onto the chip, a standard 127 μm pitch fiber array glued to the on-chip bus waveguide is used. The MRR is packaged in a standard 14-pin butterfly housing, and is equipped with an external temperature control system consisting of a TEC and a temperature sensor, as shown in Fig. 6(c-I).
Figure 6.Packaging of the MRR and generation of SMC. (a) Experimental setup diagram for the generation of fully locked SMC. Dashed box: schematic diagram of the modulation transfer spectroscopy method for locking the pump laser frequency. (b) Loaded Q-factor of the Hydex material micro-ring resonator used in the experiment. (c) Butterfly package of the MRR (c-I) and microscope photograph (c-II).
SMC generation: To ensure the long-term stability of the SMCs, SMCs are generated by the well-developed laser assisted thermal balance scheme, as shown in Fig. 6(a). However, when using an additional narrow-linewidth laser as the auxiliary, the relative frequency drift between the pump and auxiliary lasers will influence the microcomb repetition rate, even making the SMC annihilation. In our experiments, the auxiliary laser is realized by shifting the pump laser frequency. Specifically, a narrow-linewidth laser is split into two beams: one beam is used as a pump, and the other beam acts as the auxiliary after frequency shifting by using an AOM. After the pump and auxiliary light powers are amplified to 1000 mW and 800 mW, the two beams are counter coupled into the MRR through the input and through ports, respectively. Furthermore, by fine-tuning the auxiliary laser frequency and the temperature of the MRR, the generation of single solitons is achieved.
[19] L. Huang, W. Wang, F. Wang. Massively parallel Hong–Ou–Mandel interference based on independent soliton microcombs. Sci. Adv., 11, eadq8982(2025).
Long Huang, Linhan Tang, Yang Wang, Minhui Cheng, B. E. Little, Sai T. Chu, Wei Zhao, Weiqiang Wang, Wenfu Zhang, "Multi-channel Hong–Ou–Mandle interference between independent comb-based weak coherent pulses," Photonics Res. 13, 837 (2025)